Quora uses cookies to improve your experience. Read more

Why is Bill Clinton fondly referred to as the First Black President?

18 Answers
Mac Tan
Mac Tan, writer-forecaster at StatSheet, electionstatsheet.quora.com
Contrary to popular belief (which seems to be echoed in many of the existing answers), Clinton's moniker as "the first black president" wasn't pejorative and it wasn't created by racists. It was first used by Toni Morrison.

Now, not being black myself, I'm not the first person you should listen to for the following opinion, but I think many literary critics and scholars of African-American studies would agree that if any author alive today has the authority to speak about the black experience in America, it's Toni Morrison. (Read The Bluest Eye, Beloved, or Song of Solomon to see why.)

Here's what she said in a 1998 article in The New Yorker:

African-American men seemed to understand it right away. Years ago, in  the middle of the Whitewater investigation, one heard the first murmurs: white skin notwithstanding, this is our first black President. Blacker than any actual black person who could ever be elected in our children's lifetime. After all, Clinton displays almost every trope of blackness: single-parent household, born poor, working-class, saxophone-playing,  McDonald’s-and-junk-food-loving boy from Arkansas. And when virtually all the African-American Clinton appointees began, one by one, to disappear, when the President’s body, his privacy, his unpoliced sexuality became the focus of the persecution, when he was metaphorically seized and body-searched, who could gainsay these black men who knew whereof they spoke? The message was clear: “No matter how smart you are, how hard you work, how much coin you earn for us, we will put you in your place or put you out of the place you have somehow, albeit with our permission, achieved. You will be fired from your job, sent away in disgrace, and—who knows?—maybe sentenced and jailed to boot. In short, unless you do as we say (i.e., assimilate at once), your expletives belong to us.”

In part, "the first black president" reflects the fact that Bill Clinton, although white-skinned, has lived a life similar to that of many black men in America. But it's also largely a name that reflects the fact that he, as a successful white man, is nevertheless facing an environment similar to that faced by successful black men, where there is a systemic environmental tendency to demean their accomplishments and latch onto any of their failures, no matter how small. In the case of black men who rise out of poverty or troubled households, it's the system of employers or the business community or law enforcement, who all always treated black men as somehow being more worthy of suspicion or scrutiny; in the case of Clinton it's the system of Congress and (especially) the press, who both relentlessly dogged him for his perceived personal failings in a way no prior president had been dogged.

In short, it's a racial analogy to a now-famous comment made by Hillary Clinton earlier that year on The Today Show:

The great story here for anybody willing to find it and write about it and explain it is this vast right-wing conspiracy that has been conspiring against my husband since the day he announced for President.
Your feedback is private.
Is this answer still relevant and up to date?

Bill Clinton was called as the first black president by the some Americans, and due to popular belief.

This was never made for the sake of racism, and actually holds a meaning. This is known to be very notable in the life of Bill Clinton, and here is a nice reason behind it. It was said that Clinton was able to have a life just like what most black people experience in the country, despite being a white person. 

He became successful despite of those challenges, and he sees that helping black people live a better life in the long run is something that he aims for. This is one of the reasons why he was considered as a black president; because he knows well that in order to gain success, no matter what color or culture you have, there is a way as long as you persevere.

Another reason why he was considered as a black president is because he also experienced some accusations back then – much like how some black people were discriminated and questioned if they rise towards success. The congress is the one who speculates him with a lot of issues despite of the fact that he only strived hard in order to get his goals.Even his wife knows well that the issues about him are mostly controversies, and he is just doing his job rightfully as a President.

There were lots of accusations being made and so as conspiracy theories, but hey, this is what most people in modern society does whenever someone rises to fame. Just like how a hardworking black person is, despite of the accusations, he never let himself down because of that, and that is one reason why you can say that the is a black president after all.

Here are some of the issues he faced.

Margaret Plotkin
Margaret Plotkin, Political junkie since 1967. Voting continuously since 1972. That's 88 elections
Bill Clinton had an easy affability with all kinds of people, and he was particularly simpatico with blacks. He grew up poor in the South, and he had contact with blacks in a way that most whites didn't, which gave him an ease around black voters that white candidates couldn't usually match.

There was a story during his first campaign that on his first day at the University of Arkansas, he went straight to the black table in the cafeteria, put down his tray as if he belonged there, and joined the group with no self-consciousness. This was at the time when there was a book called "Why do all the black kids sit together in the cafeteria?" (Or something like that), about the development of racIal identity, so the story resonated. I have no idea of its veracity, but the fact that it was widely circulated and believed speaks to the way many black people felt that Clinton "got" them, their specific experiences and outlooks. They affectionately called him "the first black president," half as a joke. I suspect they had no idea how soon there would be an actual black president.
"Americans" never did.

Those who did are the same people who called Obama, "Islamic" or "not a citizen" or that preached in churches or on Facebook using divisive code. They are the same ones who said "W" was un-intelligent or that said that Reagan was an economic genius.
There are people who will try to trigger you to change your mind. On an emotion. There is folklore that would have you believe That having a "non american" in the woodpile is in itself a  bad thing.

it  truth. I take this back. Some "americans" at one time or another did say this. I recognize that you cannot prosecute, but you can persecute.

To William's credit, his did wear it as a badge of honor.

did he not?
Angela Stockton
Angela Stockton, retired, Kentucky native, constant reader, lifelong horse lover, news junkie

First, because he grew up in Arkansas, always had black friends, and played "black" music on his saxophone.  Then when he was impeached over his affair with Monica Lewinsky, he had something in common with black leaders who'd had extramarital affairs and been excoriated for them, such as Jesse Jackson, Martin Luther King, and Adam Clayton Powell. 

Throughout the civil rights movement, it appeared that any character flaw in a black leader was seized upon by whites in order to discredit them, even though the white critics weren't paragons themselves.  Not coincidentally, some of Clinton's harshest critics, notably Newt Gingrich, Henry Hyde, and Robert Livingston, were hiding affairs of their own.     

Muhammad Rasheed
Muhammad Rasheed, Artist, Writer, Publisher at Cartooning (2000-present)

As the first Baby Boomer President of the United States, Black Americans and the liberal youth in general, embraced Bill Clinton for some of the 'Rock-n-Roll coolness' traits he displayed while on the campaign trail. Wearing shades while playing the saxophone, and making appearances on the Arsenio Hall Show which was popular in the Black community at the time, gave the impression that Clinton was OUR president in the tradition of someone like JFK.

Unfortunately this proved to be an illusion, or at least the "doing right by his Black Democrat voters" part wasn't more important to Clinton than his political career. Clinton's strategy as POTUS was to beat the GOP on the divisive "Tough On Crime" partisan point that historically meant the difference in a close presidential race. Far from helping Blacks, as the insultingly fraudulent "First Black President" moniker suggests, Clinton's crime bills instead hit the African-American community like an atom bomb, building upon Ronald Reagan's Black Male mass incarceration program, and leaving the community even more vulnerable to greed-fueled corporatist predators.

Clinton's after-the-fact apologies came far too late, and not even Barack Obama's attempts to reform the criminal justice system could provide any immediate reversals towards several presidential terms of hostile, anti-Black policies. The community's only recent hope was to elect a genuinely apologetic Hillary Clinton to build upon Obama's work to slowly strip down those laws, but this was not to be. After wrenching the White House away from Hillary using GOP Supreme Court approved voter suppression tactics, Donald Trump picked Jeff Sessions for a key cabinet role in his new administration who -- with his long history of anti-Black community sentiments -- immediately doubled down on strengthening the policies that could only triple (at least!) the Black Male mass incarceration rate for years to come.